Jury Renders Verdict in Favor of Novell Over SCO – Linux Users Protected
Wednesday, March 31st, 2010For more than seven years, SCO and Novell (and IBM, and a number of other companies) have been in court trying to decide who owns the copyrights to UNIX. The jury has decided in favor of Novell, and we think this is good for the industry as it promotes competition, which we believe results in better-quality products at more attractive prices.
During this action, SCO threatened every Linux user with claims that Linux violated SCO’s intellectual property. Microsoft-friendly entities invested in SCO apparently to help SCO continue the litigation and, it is alleged, arm-twist risk-averse customers away from Linux and back towards using Microsoft products. Microsoft too has alleged that Linux infringes on its intellectual property as well.
A few years back, Novell made a bold move, and did a deal with Microsoft to indemnify Novell Linux users from any follow-on claims. Microsoft in turn agreed to improve interoperability with Novell’s Linux server systems, which resulted in Microsoft’s Hyper-V virtualization software being able to host Novell SuSE Linux Enterprise Server guests, among other customer benefits.
Novell was roundly trounced for doing that deal with Microsoft; “selling out” was frequently heard at the time. But we thought the deal was very shrewd on Novell’s part, for two reasons. First, Microsoft paid Novell ~$350 million, which gave Novell some extra cash to see the SCO litigation through to completion. Second, a number of our risk-averse clients who were on the fence about using Linux over Microsoft Server products could now choose between the two without worrying about any legal exposure. We ourselves continued to use Novell’s SuSE Linux server products in favor over other Linux distributions, including RedHat, in part because of this legal protection.
SCO can certainly appeal the decision, and given their history of tenacity, they might indeed do so. But yesterday’s ruling casts a long shadow protecting Linux users everywhere. And if that increasing competition spurs Microsoft towards greater innovation, then everyone benefits.
The full history of this fascinating case, and other related actions, can be found at http://www.groklaw.net.
If you need help understanding how to choose between Linux and Windows (and Macs, too!), we actively support all three platforms and would welcome the opportunity to help. Call us at (207) 772-5678.
Mark
CIO
P.S. If you’d like to subscribe to our blog, you can do so by linking to http://feeds.feedburner.com/ReliableNetworks